Thursday, February 10, 2011

LIMITATIONS TO BIG-CUBE HOMEBUILT TURBO PROJECTS, PART I

BY 460-BBF-Turbo-In-CC (from the legendary Car Craft Big-Cube Turbo Thread)

A man’s got to know his limitations.” – Harry Callahan, “Magnum Force” (1973).

The Jetfire V8 and recent Indy V8s can only provide limited guideposts for Car Crafters on turbocharging.

The comparison of these engines does show that success in turbocharging (huge torque & massive horsepower) depends on more than just sticking on any old turbo laying around.
But neither the Jetfire nor the Indy V8 would be good street/strip mills. Back in the early ‘60s, Oldsmobile dealers were often busy replacing blown head gaskets or removing Jetfire turbo systems and replacing them with four-barrel carbs. Bore corrosion was epidemic. So the Jetfire stands as a cautionary tale of what not to do.
And an Indy V8 on the street would produce horrible fuel mileage and unsatisfactory power below 5,000 r.p.m., even if you could afford the huge “buy-in,” packaging, and servicing costs. So Indy engines merely suggest general areas for improvement of street/strip turbo powerplants.
Thus, a practical PLAN for turbocharging a OEM production street/strip engine means building within the walls of a vastly different “box” of needs and performance expectations.
But before we identify our performance parameters and goals, we’ve got to take stock of the outer limits. We’ve got to know our limitations.
These limitations should be regularly consulted as we PLAN and build. They are a “reality check” on our turbocharged enthusiasm and creativity.
LIMITATIONS (Part 1):
1. Money – The big limit is always going to be money. While it’s not the same sum for every Car Crafter, everyone has a maximum budget. The only way a home turbo project becomes feasible for most Car Crafters is by avoiding the expense of custom-built parts and costly “experts” whenever possible. Thus, turbo Car Crafters are mostly stuck with mass-produced OEM and aftermarket parts and self-help labor. What is cheap and readily available often trumps what would be best.
2. Time – A close cousin to money is time. Most street/strip turbo Car Crafters are not engineers. Most are not professional fabricators. Most cannot spend every waking hour ironing out build problems or contemplating turbo tuning theory. So something that’s quick, relatively simple, and easy-to-build is almost always better than something so time-consumingly “perfect” that’s never completed.
3. Practicality – If it’s not practical, we won’t drive it very much. It’s that simple. A street/strip machine that guzzles race gas, or idles at 1500 r.p.m., or won’t start when it’s cold, or has to stop for refueling every 75 miles, or takes three hands and three feet to operate, or hides small children behind its giant hood scoop won’t stay attractive for long in the “real world, ” regardless of how “wicked” and “gnarly” it is in our imagination.

Labels: , , , , ,

PLAN back from where you want to end up.

BY 460-BBF-Turbo-In-CC (from the legendary Car Craft Big-Cube Turbo Thread)

To some Car Crafters it's self-evident why turbocharged Indy V8s "processed" more than four times more air mass than the 1960s Oldsmobile Jetfire V8. Others may just throw up their hands and mutter something about "racing engine" and "unobtainium."
But we can learn important things about planning PLAN from the Indy V8s.
While the Indy V8 engineers may have had huge budgets and the liberty to design purpose-parts (something most Car Crafters will never have), they were forced to design in a fairly restrictive rules box.
THE GOOD: The "N Factor" (number of combustion events per minute) of PLAN was rules-limited to eight cylinders and 12,000 r.p.m (although development had once taken r.p.m. levels as high as 15,000). That's 48,000 cylinder firings per minute at redline. That sounds like a lot until you realize the cubic-inch displacement factors (L & A) were limited to 2,650 cubic centimetres (161.7 cu in; 2.65 liters) That means each cylinder was only a little over 20 cubic inches.
The engines needed to last only 700 miles or less between major rebuilds. The designers were free to use many premium materials, dual overhead camshafts, multiple valves per cylinder, multi-point fuel injection and other strategies to optimize high r.p.m. power.
Fuel was detonation resistant methanol. Thus Factors A (area) and L (stroke length) were not as dependant on avoiding detonation (more on this later). And relatively high compression could be employed to extract more work from the "working fluid" (fuel + air).
THE BAD: The Indy V8s were limited to one turbocharger and very low intake manifold pressure. They could not use charge cooling (although it was hardly necessary considering the cooling effect of alcohol fuel and the low "boost" levels).
They needed to be responsive over a moderately wide r.p.m. range. They also needed to be a structural member of the chassis. But weight and packaging were restricted by chassis aerodynamics and handling considerations.
Fuel consumption and on-board capacity were both limited (limiting the amount of fuel enrichment for in-cylinder cooling). The engines needed to produce enough power to overcome extremely high-drag bodies at speeds of more than 230 m.p.h. and to accelerate 1500-1600 lbs from 35-150 m.p.h. harder than most doorslammers several times per lap on road courses.
So how did they make it work?
Mostly by concentrating on maximizing Factors P & N within the limits of the rules.
Optimizing Factor P (cylinder pressure) on low "boost" required all of the standard "all motor" hop-up techniques: Generous breathing, optimized by oversized bores (Factor A), large valve curtain area (the total amount of valve opening), large straight ports, pressure-wave tuned intakes manifolds and exhaust headers. They also increased efficiency through high compression and lowered crankcase backpressure by dry-sump scavenging (less air resistance to the power strokes from the back of the pistons).
The aerodynamics, bearings, and rotating assemblies of indy car turbochargers were also optimized for efficiency and improved responsiveness(more Factor P quicker, at lower r.p.m., and with less charge heating) Even the intake air bell was aerodynamically engineered to swirl the air into the turbocharger compressor to improve its efficiency.
To maximize Factor N, they built everything to withstand and enable sustained high r.p.m. They moved the torque peak closer to the rev limit. Stroke length (Factor L) was reduced to serve the needs of Factors N and P (bigger bores allow for more valve curtain area; shorter strokes reduce loading on the reciprocating assembly) They also helped get more of the work accomplished by Factors P & N through to the wheels by targeted reductions in rotating mass and reduced oil windage.
It should be clear that the success of the turbocharged Indy V8s didn't occur from just slapping a turbo on the engine and calling it good. The engineers instead focused on where they wanted to end up and the restrictions placed on getting there. Then they adjusted the PLAN factors to achieve their targeted results.

Labels: ,

Friday, February 04, 2011

WHAT IS "BOOST"

BY 460-BBF-Turbo-In-CC (from the legendary Car Craft Big-Cube Turbo Thread)
"Boost" can be oversimplified as resistance to air flow. Every tire on your car probably has 30+ pounds per square inch of pressure, but (hopefully) no air flow. Your shop compressor often has more than 100 psi, but at air flow volumes that are minuscule to the demands of even a low-performance automobile engine.
When we read "boost" from a tap in the intake manifold of an engine, what we're mostly reading is resistance to air flow between the compressor impeller and the cylinders. Now that's not necessarily a bad thing. Resistance to flow between the compressor impeller and the compressor housing is part of how any centrifugal compressor increases air density.
But it should be apparent that a high "boost" level doesn't necessarily mean high mass air flow into the engine. 14 psi of non-chargecooled "boost" through a Stromberg 97 on an asthmatic flathead V8 isn't going to result in as much mass air flow as 14 psi of cooled "boost" through a modern EcoBoost V6.
In other words "boost" is relative.
A great example of this is comparing the ancient Oldsmobile Jetfire V8 to the last of the turbocharged Indy V8s. Both were non-charge cooled, single turbo engines. Both engines ran less than 6 psi of turbo "boost." The Indy V8 was rules-limited to a mere 161.7 cubic inch displacement. The Oldsmobile Jetfire displaced 215 cubic inches. Yet the mass of air consumed by a turbo Indy V8 was roughly four times more than the Jetfire Olds. And it was at a lower peak boost level to boot! (4.91 psi initially and reduced to 1.96 psi by the end of the Indy turbo V8 era).
So the lesson here is that turbo Car Crafters should be focusing mass air flow instead of "boost." "Boost" is good for bragging, but it's mass air flow that wins races.Forget the old saw "there's no substitute for cubic inches." The truth is that there's no substitute for mass air flow.**
(**Okay the nitrous oxide fans may carp at this last point, but N20 injection is merely substituting part of the ordinary air mass for a higher quality (more oxygen-rich) gas supplied under high pressure. So it is is in essence a form of increasing mass flow)

Labels: , , , ,

WHAT IS THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG? It is a real-time on-line book about the theory and practice of turbocharging B-I-G CUBE V8 Engines.

what is this?

Tell me when this blog is updated. . .

  • Copyright 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2017. All Rights Reserved. The BIG-CUBIC INCH TURBO BLOG may be quoted with attribution and/or linking to the original post at "THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG", subject to the Fair Use provisions and limitations of U.S. Copyright law. The trademarks and service marks appearing herein are the property of their respective owners and "Truth With Hydra and Cammie: The Lifter Sisterz" and its predecessor are not affiliated in any way with the holders of these trademarks and service marks. Such trademarks and servicemarks appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law. Truth With Hydra and Cammie claims no copyright interest in photos, videos, and articles linked here from internet sources. All materials linked here are for a non-commecial purpose and appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law.