Thursday, September 07, 2006

WARRANTY WAR: GM ONE-UPS FORD, BUT STILL TRAILS THE KOREANS

Yesterday, September 6, 2006, General Motors announced a new Five Year/100,000 mile powertrain warranty for all 2007 model vehicles sold in the United States and Canada, according to the Automotive News. www.autonews.com See also www.gm.com/warranty.
The new warranty replaced GM's standard three year/36,000 mile warranty and is fully transferrable and free of deductibles.
"The move is a bid by GM to counter successful marketing of long-term warranties by competitors such as Hyundai and Kia." www.autonews.com
Of course, GM's warranty volley is also in the context of Ford Motor Company's own escalation of the burgeoning "warranty war." FoMoCo jacked up the powertrain coverage on 2007 Fords and Mercurys to five years or 60,000 miles and on Lincolns to six years or 70,000 miles.
"'What we’ve found is that two-thirds of customers trade or dispose of the vehicle before five years and 100,000 miles,' said Mark LaNeve, GM's vice president of vehicle sales, service and marketing. 'This really matches the way customers buy cars.'"
The truth is that these enhanced warranties are simply a disguised sales incentive. However, they provide long-lasting psychological effects not available from one-time hits, such as rebates, employee pricing or zero-percent financing.
From a business perspective, long warranties are simply bundled repair insurance. For aftermarket service warranties, the warranty company's bet is that the premiums they collect from warranty sales will exceed their repair and administration costs.
But in the minds of consumers, a long warranty is a "guarantee" of reliablity. The consumers's logic is that the manufacturer wouldn't (and couldn't) "guarantee" a vehicle for so long if they thought it was going to break down. Thus, these enhanced warranties create "peace of mind" in consumers and, correspondingly, higher quality perceptions for the brand. This feeling is further extended by "roadside assistance" benefits that are copied from aftermarket "extended warranty" plans.
At least that's what the manufacturers hope.
It's not the first time we've been down this road. In the early 1960s, Lincoln shocked the automotive world by offering an unprecedented 24,000 mile warranty on its new "Kennedy" Continental. http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,894536,00.html Lincoln's problem then, as now, was that it badly trailed Cadillac in sales and perceptions of the brand's quality were not the best. The "long" warranty sought to garner attention for the "all new" Continental and to "one-up" Cadillac.
Chrysler played a similar game years later with its "5/50" protection plan.
FoMoCo boosted warranties on Ford Focus a few years back to offset a spate of negative publicty surrounding a number of recalls.
Of course, the Koreans have been the most aggressive in using warranties to assuage consumer angst about quality. In the 1980s -- when Consumer Reports was really emerging as a de facto promotional vehicle of the Japanese automakers (albeit with no "smoking gun" ever uncovered linking any coordination or collusion) -- Korean cars reportedly lagged in the quality cellar. Perhaps only the Yugo and maybe Jaguar had a worse reputation for quality back then.
To combat the widespread public perception that Korean cars were cheap, flimsy and of minimal quality, Korean manufacturers began offering dramatically extended warranties "for free" (e.g. warranty cost was burried in the sales price). Now Korean warranties extend as long as 10 years/100,000 miles.
Some would argue that the Koreans' aggressive promotion of warranties has saved their businesses in the U.S. and permitted them to move up-market more rapidly than would ordinarily be possible.
GM and FoMoCo dealers probably have mixed emotions about the escalating "warranty war." Undoubtedly they see the warranties as better than simply putting more "cash on the hood" with rebates and other discounts. Moreover, they probably expect these moves to counteract some of the misperceptions about "Detroit" quality signficantly lagging behind the Japanese. And undoubtedly they welcome the increased opportunities for service work under the warranties, although compensated by the factories at controversial "warranty flat rates."
But the dealers will miss some of the profits from the "F&I" department that the combination of short factory warranties and generous aftermarket "extended warranties" provided. Extended warranties have a 50% or better (sometimes MUCH better) gross profit margin. And in many states, sales are relatively unregulated, so dealers can keep all the difference from the transaction price (which the dealer generally sets) and the cost to "buy" the warranty from the service warranty company. (However, some warranty companies have a "charge back" provision if a dealer's warranty claims become excessive) And although the new, longer "powertrain protection" warranties do still preserve room for aftermarket "bumper-to-bumper" warranties, selling them to skeptical customers will be more of a challenge.
Similarly, these moves may also deprive some revenue from GMAC and Ford Motor Credit, both of which offer extended warranty products. But the manufacturers also realize that warranties are a deferred, contingent cost (excluding any reserves for such repairs and promotional costs), unlike rebates and discounts which always hit the bottom line immediately. And they recognize that warranties add perceived value without cheapening transaction prices, thus benefiting residual values and, thus, improving perceptions of brand's lasting value.
It's unlikely that GM's move is the final shot in the current "warranty war." FoMoCo may be unable to stay at less than 100,000 miles. And market pressures will likely force the Detroit 3 to move closer and closer to complete "bumper-to-bumper" coverage.
New FoMoCo CEO Alan Mulally is probably now wondering what sort of business he's got himself into. After all, Boeing usually sold its aircraft to sophisticated business customers with their own staffs of highly-trained mechanics, operating under the scrutiny of the FAA or other aviation authorities. This business about dealers, warranty repair rates, public perceptions and the "warranty war" is fresh ground for him.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

WHAT IS THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG? It is a real-time on-line book about the theory and practice of turbocharging B-I-G CUBE V8 Engines.

what is this?

Tell me when this blog is updated. . .

  • Copyright 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2017. All Rights Reserved. The BIG-CUBIC INCH TURBO BLOG may be quoted with attribution and/or linking to the original post at "THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG", subject to the Fair Use provisions and limitations of U.S. Copyright law. The trademarks and service marks appearing herein are the property of their respective owners and "Truth With Hydra and Cammie: The Lifter Sisterz" and its predecessor are not affiliated in any way with the holders of these trademarks and service marks. Such trademarks and servicemarks appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law. Truth With Hydra and Cammie claims no copyright interest in photos, videos, and articles linked here from internet sources. All materials linked here are for a non-commecial purpose and appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law.