Friday, September 01, 2006

IS IT WILLIAM CLAY FORD, JR.'S FAULT?

In a column entitled "Bill Ford has reached defining moment," Daniel Howes writes a spirited defense of the embattled Ford scion and Ford Motor Company (tm) C.E.O.
In Howes's mind, the real problem is in all those myopic Wall Street wonks and know-it-all FoMoCo retirees, neither of which recognize that Ford's problems started long before Bill Jr's watch.
Perhaps tacitly acknowledging the emerging "Waiting for Ghosn" cult, Old Detroiter Howes opines "But Bill Ford isn't going anywhere, which doesn't guarantee he'll be CEO until he's 60 because he doesn't have to be. He's an owner and -- this is the important part -- will be regardless of his title, meaning he has more skin riding on his company's future than any other industry CEO." http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060901/AUTO02/609010427/1148
Of course the problem with Howes's defense of Bill Jr. is that it simply ignores the facts:
1. FoMoCo's market share has declined for NINE STRAIGHT YEARS, dating back to the twin failures of the 1996 Taurus "Fishmobile" and the too-cramped-for-Real-Americans Mondeo/Contour (a/k/a the "Junior Fishmobile").
2. Bill Jr. has been in a position to influence the direction of FoMoCo since 1999 (and arguably even earlier given his family's extensive holdings) And in the wake of Jac "the Knife" Nasser's failures--epitomized by FoMoCo's failed internet strategy and the Explorer-Firestone fiasco, Bill Jr. has been in the top job since October 2001.
3. If Bill Jr. had "the answers" wouldn't we have seen them in the nearly FIVE YEARS he's been at the controls? Instead, we've got a huge list of fits, starts, flip-flops and missed opportunities.
4. Bill Jr. may eventually recognize, as his uncle Henry II did over fifty years ago, that having one's name on the building doesn't make one an expert in the car business. He's taken some steps in that direction with the elevation of Mark Fields and the creation of a "Management Committee" after finally purging out all those "retirees" Howes blames for FoMoCo's decline. But Bill Jr.'s epiphany won't come soon enough to undo the damage of the wasted 2001-2006 period.
5. The CD3 and D3 sedans "developed" (mostly cribbed from Volvo and Mazda) on Bill Jr.'s watch are underwhelming and arguably uncompetitive. FoMoCo' sedans are down on BOTH horsepower and fuel economy to much of the competition.
6. Bill Jr.'s FoMoCo has let profitable niches, such as the police car and livery trade, rot by mostly stopping development of the Panther and this neglect has drastically weakened the retail demand for these unique models (Why buy a new car that looks like a 1998 model and has less power than a new Honda?).
7. While Bill Jr. did permit a redesigned Mustang for 2005, his bean counters saddled it with weak engine internals, too few variants to adequately cover the market, less than optimal fuel economy and inadequate power in the mass-produced GT model.
8. While Bill Jr. did permit the GT supercar and the Shelby GT500, he starved SVT and Ford Racing Performance Parts, decimated the number of FoMoCo supported NASCAR teams (reducing Ford's chances to Beat GM, DCX and now Toyota on the track), failed to engineer a return to Indianapolis, squandered the valuable Cosworth legacy, and killed FoMoCo's decades-long tradition in Formula One participation without replacing it with another high-profile international competition alternative.
9. Bill Jr.'s FoMoCo has failed to recognize and adapt to the resurgence of rear wheel drive in premium, luxury and high performance niches.
10. Bill Jr. failed to have a contingency plan for $3.00/gallon fuel prices, which have been foreseeable for a long time.
11. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo failed to properly develop the Focus as a viable alternative to Honda and Toyota (and now Scion) in the youth market.
12. On Bill Jr.'s watch, the 6.0 PowerStroke fiasco damaged FoMoCo's truck reputation and allowed DCX and GM time to catch up in turbo-diesels.
13. On Bill Jr.'s watch, the new F-150 came in too heavy, without high performance options, without manual transmissions, without fuel-saving multivalve engine technology, and without turbo diesel engine options.
14. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo's minivans have lagged the competition in power, economy, innovation and marketshare. Now FoMoCo is giving up on the segment, in favor of "people movers."
15. On Bill Jr.'s watch, an unnecesary and divisive "boycott" has damaged FoMoCo's dealer base, especially in the "Bible belt" without yielding any particular benefits to the company otherwise.
16. On Bill Jr.'s watch, Ford's SUVs have continued to decline in marketshare, notwithstanding redesigns, because they lack sufficient power, economy and value to stay competitive (especially in trendy niches such as luxury SUVs).
17. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo has failed and refused to adopt new technologies, such as cylinder deactivation, "twin-charging," turbocharging (in North America), electric-clutched superchargers, broad use of variable intake runner technology, broad use of variable valve lift and timing, and even off-the-shelf multivalve heads in some applications.
18. On Bill Jr.s' watch, the 3.5 Duratec, which is touted by some as FoMoCo's "engine of the future" came to market late and down on power to the Japanese competition.
19. On Bill Jr.'s watch, Lincoln slipped further behind Cadillac and began its ill-advised move downward into the morass of "near luxury."
20. On Bill Jr.'s watch, the Japanese took virtually all of the praise and adoration for development of hybrid-electric vehicles, while FoMoCo stalled, delayed and flip-flopped in this image-building (yet otherwise relatively meaningless) segment.
21. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo continued its failure to offer any affordable alternative to Chevrolet's Corvette.
22. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo basically killed the storied Thunderbird nameplate with an effete, boulevard poser in the obviously failed mold of Chrysler's Maserati TC, Buick's Reatta, and Cadillac's Allante.
23. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo flipflopped on the "Hurricane" truck engine project and failed to leverage its advantages in multivalve overhead cam engines in V8 markets (while the Japanese continued to make inroads with their DOHC Four-Valve V8s and V6s, and DCX and GM dominated the large V8 market).
24. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo failed to take any marketshare away from GM in the opinion-leading aftermarket repower niche. FoMoCo's line of "crate engines" simply aren't competitive on variety, price, features or availability.
25. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo failed to develop a competitive sub-Focus subcompact for the North American Market.
26. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo allowed the Taurus to decline into a fleet car sold at commodity prices and failed to develop competitive alternatives to Toyota Camry and Honda Civic.
27. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo failed to make use of Eaton supercharger technology (except in a few expensive niche and import models), notwithstanding that it had mostly funded the development of it. However, DCX, GM and others have greatly benefitted from this "Ford" technology.
28, On Bill Jr.'s watch, Mercury has floundered as a badge-engineered marque with a lack of clear direction and poor sales, despite having an exemplary initial quality.
29. Bill Jr. has failed to solve the paralysis-by-analysis problem fostered by FoMoCo's committee system, causing products that do make it through to be too late to market, too conservative, tepid in design and generally uncompetitive.
30. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo's sales have continued to shrink, declining 12% in the most recent sales month (August 2006) to 255,112--notwithstanding a blow-out Zero percent financing sale and increased warranty coverage.
31. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo hasn't developed a reliable method to locate "stars" in the automotive world, attract them into the FoMoCo's orbit, and to empower them to build legendary motorcars.
32. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo has failed to leverage its associations with Panoz, Roush, Saleen, Steeda, MG, Noble and Morgan by providing them with power-adder ready DOHC 4V engines at reasonable costs, and exploiting the favorable publicity from the "Powered by Ford" niche marques.
33. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo failed to develop the Lincoln LS as a viable alternative to Japanese, American and European sports sedans, instead allowing it to atrophy and die before its time.
34. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo has failed to appropriately identify and apply the essential "brand DNA" of its various nameplates, leading to such fiascos as pouring millions into Jaguar in the hope that it would be successful selling Mondeo-based compacts and ignoring FoMoCo's legacy as the company which brought low-cost V8 power to the masses (ironically, none of FoMoCo's latest sedans will accept a FoMoCo V8) .
35. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo neglected the compact truck segment, allowing Ranger to age ungracefully, while competitiors continued to invest in the segment.
36. On Bill Jr.'s watch, FoMoCo's stakeholders, such as its salaried workforce, its union workforce, its dealers, its suppliers, the communities which depend on these groups of stakeholders, and ultimately, FoMoCo's loyal customers, have all suffered by virtue of the foregoing FoMoCo failures and others too numerous to mention.
So, although Daniel Howes is probably right that Bill Jr. isn't "going anywhere," it is highly disingenuous to suggest that he cannot or should not be held responsible for FoMoCo's continuing decline.
Bill Ford's "defining moment" occurred long ago.
His watch has been a failure. His legacy will be always be one of abject inadequacy and missed opportunities. Only because his "name is on the building" and his family controls his future has he survived this long, given FoMoCo's deepening crisis.
He ought to be held responsible. At least somebody should . . . .

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

WHAT IS THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG? It is a real-time on-line book about the theory and practice of turbocharging B-I-G CUBE V8 Engines.

what is this?

Tell me when this blog is updated. . .

  • Copyright 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2017. All Rights Reserved. The BIG-CUBIC INCH TURBO BLOG may be quoted with attribution and/or linking to the original post at "THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG", subject to the Fair Use provisions and limitations of U.S. Copyright law. The trademarks and service marks appearing herein are the property of their respective owners and "Truth With Hydra and Cammie: The Lifter Sisterz" and its predecessor are not affiliated in any way with the holders of these trademarks and service marks. Such trademarks and servicemarks appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law. Truth With Hydra and Cammie claims no copyright interest in photos, videos, and articles linked here from internet sources. All materials linked here are for a non-commecial purpose and appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law.