Tuesday, September 05, 2006

INVESTOR'S CRITICISM OF "THE WAY FORWARD"

Ford Motor Company's "Way Forward" has been roundly analysed and even criticized. One of the more concise criticisms is found at Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis: The Way Forward.

Notwithstanding that FoMoCo is still developing its latest plan, Mish summarizes what he thinks we know so far about the "Way Forward" as follows:


"1. Cut 4th quarter production 21%
2. Offer 0% financing for 6 years
3. Court Nissan
4. Sell Jaguar and Land Rover
5. Reduce list prices as compared to 2006
6. Close 14 North American plants
7. Eliminate 30,000 jobs in the US
8. Create 150,000 assembly jobs in Mexico
7. Increase Mexican made components by 300%
8. Shift some professional engineering and purchasing jobs to Mexico
9. Offer worker buyouts
10. (If all else fails) Take the company private"

Of course the foregoing summary adopts some speculative points (such as the extent of FoMoCo "Run to the Border" or whether "Waiting for Ghosn" is wishful thinking) and doesn't capture others (such as FoMoCo's increasing reliance on Mazda and Volvo for platforms and engine technology, FoMoCo's increase in warranty lengths, and FoMoCo's abandonment of the true luxury market for its Lincoln brand). It also inflates temporary tactical measures, such as the zero-percent clearance sale to major points of "The Way Forward."

Still, Mish identifies two questions suggested by his summary.

A. "Is this plan the "Way Forward" or are these acts of desperation?"

While certainly a judgment call, Speedzzter has often argued that "The Way Forward" smacks more of desperation than a real plan at "right sizing" and establishing the necessary predicate to recapture market share. Moreover, it is unclear whether the "Way Forward" actually addresses the cultural and institutional factors which led to the loss of FoMoCo's edge and nine-year decline. In some ways, the points cited are not unlike railroads in the mid 20th Century cutting back on routes and services in search of profits.

B. "After all the jobs and parts are moved to Mexico and China will Ford still be running ads to 'Buy American'?"

What ads to "buy American?"

Obviously Mish is being sarcastic, playing off of Bill Ford's occassional "driving American innovation" commercials, but this point deserves a little serious analysis.

The Detroit 3 have all been reluctant to play the nationalism card due in part to the international complexity of the automobile business and, likely, fears of somehow being labeled "racist." Thus, they have not effectively used guilt and national pride as a motivation to attack foreign invaders and call selfish and unreliable Americans "home" to products designed and built in the U.S.A. While FoMoCo is based in the U.S.A. and still employs more "Americans" than all the transplants combind, it operates as a multinational corporation with few parochial ties. That indicates that what is best for FoMoCo may not be best for America, and vice versa.

The dwendling number of FoMoCo faithful probably would relish it if Ford made a substantive argument for buying American, even with the caveats of international sourcing (caused by production efficiencies, lax government oversight and idiotic disincentives to domestic production). But FoMoCo will never take the "bold move" to attack on nationalistic grounds or point to the harm that internationalization is creating in America's withering industrial base.

And as troubling as FoMoCo's substantiated and rumored future investments in Mexican production capacity are, it is unfair to suggest that "all" the jobs are moving across the Rio Grande. Some will move to China or other lower-wage regimes. Others will remain in Dearborn or other U.S. venues (at least until such time as FoMoCo is acquired by some foreign multinational).

The real problem is that no one has created a "Harley-Davidson" moment in the minds of the customers. Customers aren't led to believe there is anything unique or special about Automobiles done in the American ideom. Automobiles are widely viewed as a somewhat fungible commodity. None of the manufacturers are making the case for "American innovation" (notwithstanding FoMoCo's occassional references to it). In fact, most builders seem to run FROM Americanism (except Toyota, who is desperately trying to convince everybody that it's as "American" as "hotdogs, apple pie and Chevrolet"). For example, DCX's Dr. Z promotes "German engineering" and William Clay Ford, Jr. himself lauds the wonders of "Volvo" (Swedish) safety. These metamessages play into the long-standing immigrant ethos favoring things that are "not invented here."

For years, "old Europe" was the traditional repository of craftsmanship. Stereotypically, Italy and France led in design, Germany in technology and the United Kingdom in efficiency and quirky, sporting innovations. The emergence of the Asians as a technological force, together with the decline in the Continental work ethic (coinciding with the rise of European socialism) have shifted these perceptions somewhat, but not their ultimate result. "Not invented here" still reigns supreme in American consumerism.

The Far East has emerged as the go-to source for compact electronic technologies and exceedingly reliable systems (notwithstanding that much of the fundamental research behind these came from North America).

Now car buyers in masse ignore the objective results from J.D. Power surveys and even their own showroom perceptions in favor of a herd mentality and the intangible "zen" of Asian automobiles.

Even "old Europe" has suffered. But instead of contracting and waiting to be overwhelmed, many of Europe's surviving manufacturers have continued to seeking advancement of the art and science of automobility.

The salient questions then become, how does FoMoCo tap nationalism in America and how is it advancing the art and science of the automobile.

In short, if FoMoCo's "Way Forward" isn't about both, then it might as well move "all the jobs" to the lowest cost producer and watch its marketshare sink on average one full percentage point per year into oblivion. If FoMoCo believes that if can build a better, more soulless transporation appliance than the Asians, it's sadly mistaken. Detroit's Woodward Avenue wasn't packed a couple of weeks ago to celebrate the Asian hybrid or the perfect Asian minivan!

The "Way Forward" here must recapture the American spirit and actually drive--not just talk about driving-- American innovation.

Cribbing Volvos and Mazdas and assembling them in Mexico just doesn't cut it under this standard.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

WHAT IS THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG? It is a real-time on-line book about the theory and practice of turbocharging B-I-G CUBE V8 Engines.

what is this?

Tell me when this blog is updated. . .

  • Copyright 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2017. All Rights Reserved. The BIG-CUBIC INCH TURBO BLOG may be quoted with attribution and/or linking to the original post at "THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG", subject to the Fair Use provisions and limitations of U.S. Copyright law. The trademarks and service marks appearing herein are the property of their respective owners and "Truth With Hydra and Cammie: The Lifter Sisterz" and its predecessor are not affiliated in any way with the holders of these trademarks and service marks. Such trademarks and servicemarks appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law. Truth With Hydra and Cammie claims no copyright interest in photos, videos, and articles linked here from internet sources. All materials linked here are for a non-commecial purpose and appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law.