Wednesday, December 10, 2008

IS THE REPUBLICAN ALTERNATIVE RESCUE PLAN FOR THE DETROIT 3 AN OLIVE BRANCH OR A LOGJAM?

[Get the latest "Truth With Speedzzter" here]

The G.O.P. has finally shown up with something other than chanting Senator Shelby's "Let'em fail" mantra. Some may see this as a positive sign . . . an olive branch. But what of the details?

GOP Leaders Propose American Automotive Reorganization and Recovery Plan

The Democratic Bailout proposal has three fundamental flaws:

• The only thing crazier than trusting the same management and union officials who got the Big Three into this mess to get them out is trusting a bunch of Washington politicians and bureaucrats – the very same people who ran up a $455 billion deficit last year. American auto workers and their families deserve better.

• If no private investors believe the Big Three restructuring plans are realistic enough to support with their own money, why should we put up taxpayer money? American taxpayers deserve better.

• The Big Three restructuring plan and the Democratic proposal lack accountability. There is no guarantee that once they get taxpayer money the restructuring they promise will occur. Once the taxpayers prop them up once, there will be a big incentive to keep bailing them out – keeping the industry dependent on government aid, lashing it to the majority’s political agenda, and further denying American auto workers the security of a viable industry that is back on its feet and ready to compete. American auto workers and their families deserve better.

What We Should Be Doing: The American Automotive Reorganization and Recovery Plan

Hard Benchmarks:

On December 2, the Big Three presented to Congress their plans for restructuring. While the plans included laudable goals, too few details were provided as to how the companies will actually achieve the restructuring and the savings they have promised. In some instances new agreements to achieve the savings would not be entered into for months or perhaps years.

The Big Three must lock in the restructuring they have promised in a matter of weeks, not months or years. Congress should instead establish firm benchmarks and a tight timeline for restructuring. Such benchmarks will include for example requiring that by March 31, 2009 each company should reach agreement whereby:

• The companies’ creditors agree to a framework to reduce each company’s indebtedness by at least 1/3.

• The UAW holds to concessions already made and further:
o Concedes the elimination of Supplemental Unemployment Benefits;
o Concedes elimination of the Jobs Bank Program;
o Agrees to either reduce company retiree health care obligations or otherwise convert a portion of such obligations into equity; and
o Agrees to reduce wages and benefits to the levels paid by non-Big Three manufacturers.

A Process for Reaching Expedited Agreement, Instead of Nationalizing America’s Auto Companies

Because of the many legal and contractual hurdles to restructuring, the companies are urged to accomplish their restructuring through the use of a pre-packaged bankruptcy or another mechanism to bring all stakeholders to the table for an agreed-upon determination of their future. It is important that these stakeholders reach reasonable compromises amongst themselves. Creating a government bureaucracy or a “car czar” to arbitrarily pass judgment on the thousands of details involved with a restructuring is akin to nationalizing the auto companies.

Interim Financing: Insurance, Rather than a Taxpayer-Funded Bailout

The Big Three may need some form of interim financing as they finalize their restructuring. In normal economic times, if their restructuring plan is considered viable, such financing should be available in the private market. Because of the current credit crisis, limited assistance may be appropriate in the form of insurance, rather than a taxpayer-funded government bailout that replaces private investment. We propose that the government provide insurance, funded by the participants with a modest FDIC-like fee, which would cover up to 50% of the losses of new investment in the case of default, helping to unlock immediate private investment (not unlike debtor in possession financing). Such insurance would expire on March 31, 2009. This proposal ensures that taxpayers are protected and provides a powerful incentive for the Big Three to quickly implement their restructuring plans.


Although some of the more onerous provisions of the OBAMAcrats' rescue plan are apparently dying (i.e. the ban on automaker lawsuits against state-level emission regulations), the emergence of the GOP counter-proposal indicates that a rescue of the Detroit 3 is far from done.

The GOP plan -- which may not even have the support of all GOP legislators -- probably has enough poison pills to prevent passage. Certainly the OBAMAcrats will do the bidding of the U.A.W. long enough to pass the ball into the upcoming OBAMAcrat Congress. But could GM and Chrysler hold on until then?

If the GOP plan were to pass, could any of the Detroit 3 meet all of the benchmarks in less than one quarter? And under the current credit crunch, would a 50% guaranty be sufficient to move billions in private capital into emergency loans for the Automakers?

While the GOP plan tries hard to avoid the dreaded "bailout" label and sidesteps some of the "nationalization" provisions of the OBAMAcrat plan, its viability -- both politically and operationally -- is questionable.

Thus, it seems that the GOP plan is merely a political cover play calculated to permit the few remaining auto state Republicans a safer vote. It will likely be used by those opposing any help in cleaning up the mess government created as a logjam to any emergency relief.

It is unclear whether the OBAMAcrats even have enough votes to choke off a possible filibuster.

It is certainly shaping up to be a long, cold December for General Motors and Chrysler.

Labels: , , ,

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

WHAT IS THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG? It is a real-time on-line book about the theory and practice of turbocharging B-I-G CUBE V8 Engines.

what is this?

Tell me when this blog is updated. . .

  • Copyright 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2017. All Rights Reserved. The BIG-CUBIC INCH TURBO BLOG may be quoted with attribution and/or linking to the original post at "THE BIG CUBIC-INCH TURBO BLOG", subject to the Fair Use provisions and limitations of U.S. Copyright law. The trademarks and service marks appearing herein are the property of their respective owners and "Truth With Hydra and Cammie: The Lifter Sisterz" and its predecessor are not affiliated in any way with the holders of these trademarks and service marks. Such trademarks and servicemarks appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law. Truth With Hydra and Cammie claims no copyright interest in photos, videos, and articles linked here from internet sources. All materials linked here are for a non-commecial purpose and appear herein under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law.