REID, LIBERALS TORPEDO HOPES FOR A 2008 DETROIT 3 "LIFELINE" DEAL
[Get the latest "Truth With Speedzzter" here]
Senate Majority Leader "Dirty" Harry Reid (D-NV) upstaged a bipartisan news conference on a supposed plan to rescue the Detroit 3 automakers.
No deal and no possiblity of one until General Motors, Ford and Chrysler can prove "viability." Nothing is expected to happen until after the plans are due on December 2.
WHY NOT JUST FILE BANKRUPTCY?
A viability plan sounds a lot like a "plan of reorganization" in bankruptcy.
So why not cut out Congress, file bankruptcy, reject the current UAW contracts and obtain the other protections of a debtor-in-possession?
It's all about customer confidence.
The marketing studies that the Detroit 3 have undertaken suggest that too many consumers would lose confidence in a bankruptcy scenario.
Risking $500 on an airline ticket is not really the same thing as buying a complex $50,000 vehicle that may at some point need a warranty or collision repair (even the Japanese "invader" dealerships have service departments). Not enough consumers would be willing to risk $15,000 to $50,000 on a company that might not be around until the product warranty runs out.
Loss of consumer confidence doomed Studebaker, Packard and others in earlier times.
For a successful chapter 11 reorganization, the automakers would need sufficient post-petition sales to generate enough cash flow and post-petition financing to confirm a workable plan of reorganization. Otherwise, the case would become a "liquidating 11" or be converted to a chapter 7 liquidation.
Moreover, in the current credit crunch, post-petition financing is a real issue. To successfully emerge from chapter 11, the Debtor-in-possession has to have post-petition financing in place BEFORE FILING. If the Detroit 3 could raise that kind of money, why wouldn't they have already tapped it?
Sure, the UAW is a huge part of the problem. But the companies have to stay afloat long enough to address it.
Denying the Detroit 3 a "lifeline" is like complaining that a drowning man is too fat for rescue. "He'll just die anyway. We're prolonging the inevitable" Pull him out of the water first, then work on necessary diet and exercise.
Washinton's policies created this problem and Congress should be responsible enough to start fixing it in a timely manner.
Bankruptcy is not a realistic option. Neither is waiting on more Congressional fumbling of the football.
[Get the latest "Truth With Speedzzter" here]
Senate Majority Leader "Dirty" Harry Reid (D-NV) upstaged a bipartisan news conference on a supposed plan to rescue the Detroit 3 automakers.
No deal and no possiblity of one until General Motors, Ford and Chrysler can prove "viability." Nothing is expected to happen until after the plans are due on December 2.
WHY NOT JUST FILE BANKRUPTCY?
A viability plan sounds a lot like a "plan of reorganization" in bankruptcy.
So why not cut out Congress, file bankruptcy, reject the current UAW contracts and obtain the other protections of a debtor-in-possession?
It's all about customer confidence.
The marketing studies that the Detroit 3 have undertaken suggest that too many consumers would lose confidence in a bankruptcy scenario.
Risking $500 on an airline ticket is not really the same thing as buying a complex $50,000 vehicle that may at some point need a warranty or collision repair (even the Japanese "invader" dealerships have service departments). Not enough consumers would be willing to risk $15,000 to $50,000 on a company that might not be around until the product warranty runs out.
Loss of consumer confidence doomed Studebaker, Packard and others in earlier times.
For a successful chapter 11 reorganization, the automakers would need sufficient post-petition sales to generate enough cash flow and post-petition financing to confirm a workable plan of reorganization. Otherwise, the case would become a "liquidating 11" or be converted to a chapter 7 liquidation.
Moreover, in the current credit crunch, post-petition financing is a real issue. To successfully emerge from chapter 11, the Debtor-in-possession has to have post-petition financing in place BEFORE FILING. If the Detroit 3 could raise that kind of money, why wouldn't they have already tapped it?
Sure, the UAW is a huge part of the problem. But the companies have to stay afloat long enough to address it.
Denying the Detroit 3 a "lifeline" is like complaining that a drowning man is too fat for rescue. "He'll just die anyway. We're prolonging the inevitable" Pull him out of the water first, then work on necessary diet and exercise.
Washinton's policies created this problem and Congress should be responsible enough to start fixing it in a timely manner.
Bankruptcy is not a realistic option. Neither is waiting on more Congressional fumbling of the football.
Labels: Bankruptcy, Chrysler, Detroit Bailout, Economic Crisis, Ford Motor Company, GM, Harry Reid



0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home